Polity ยท Chapter 05

๐ŸŽ–๏ธ President & Vice President

Election, powers, emergency provisions and pardoning power.

๐ŸŽ–๏ธ Constitutional Head of State

The President of India is the constitutional head of state and the first citizen. Article 52โ€“62 deal with the President. India follows the parliamentary system โ€” President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers (Art 74). The President is the nominal executive; the real executive is the PM and Cabinet.

Election: Elected indirectly by an Electoral College consisting of elected members of both Houses of Parliament + elected members of all state Legislative Assemblies (and Delhi/Puducherry assemblies). Votes are weighted. Method: Single transferable vote with proportional representation.

Term: 5 years. Eligible for re-election (no limit). Minimum age: 35. Must be Indian citizen. Must be qualified for Lok Sabha membership.

Powers of President:
โ€ข Executive โ€” all executive actions in name of President, appoints PM, ministers, governors, judges
โ€ข Legislative โ€” summons/prorogues Parliament, dissolves Lok Sabha, addresses joint session, nominates 12 RS members
โ€ข Financial โ€” Money Bill needs prior recommendation, presents budget
โ€ข Judicial โ€” pardoning power (Art 72): pardon, reprieve, respite, remission, commutation
โ€ข Emergency โ€” declares National (352), State (356), Financial (360) Emergency

๐Ÿ”‘ Veto powers of President

Absolute veto โ€” withholds assent to a Bill. Rare โ€” used for private member bills or state bills reserved by Governor.
Suspensive veto โ€” returns Bill for reconsideration. If Parliament passes again โ†’ President MUST give assent (no pocket veto).
Pocket veto โ€” neither gives assent nor returns. Constitutional provision for "reasonable time" โ€” no time limit specified. India has this unlike USA which has strict 10-day limit.
Note: President has NO veto for Money Bills โ€” must give assent. Constitutional Amendment Bills โ€” must give assent (Shankari Prasad case).

๐Ÿ“‹ Impeachment (Article 61) + Vice President

Impeachment: For violation of Constitution. Initiated in either house. 14 days notice. 2/3 majority of total membership of that house. Other house investigates and passes with 2/3 majority. No Indian President has been impeached yet.
Vice President (Art 63โ€“71): Elected by members of BOTH houses (not state assemblies). Ex-officio Chairman of Rajya Sabha. Acts as President when office vacant. Current VP: Jagdeep Dhankhar (2022). Current President: Droupadi Murmu (2022) โ€” first tribal woman President.

๐ŸŽฌ

President's Powers โ€” Emergency Provisions

Animation
3 TYPES OF EMERGENCY โ€” CLICK EACH ๐Ÿšจ NATIONAL EMERGENCY Article 352 Grounds: War, external aggression or armed rebellion Cabinet must advise in writing Parliament approval: 1 month Special majority: 2/3 + 50% Art 19 freedoms suspended State under Centre control Lok Sabha term extended Proclaimed: 1962, 1971, 1975 ๐Ÿ›๏ธ STATE EMERGENCY Article 356 (President Rule) Grounds: Constitutional machinery failed in state On Governor report or President satisfaction Parliament: 2 months State legislature suspended Parliament governs state Max duration: 3 years Used 100+ times since 1950 ๐Ÿ’ธ FINANCIAL EMERGENCY Article 360 Grounds: Financial stability or credit of India threatened Parliament: 2 months Simple majority sufficient Centre can direct states on financial matters Judges salary can be reduced Money bills reviewed by Centre NEVER proclaimed in India CLICK AN EMERGENCY TYPE India has had 3 National Emergencies (1962, 1971, 1975), 100+ State Emergencies, and 0 Financial Emergencies.

1975 Emergency (Art 352) by PM Indira Gandhi was the most controversial โ€” called the darkest chapter of Indian democracy.

๐Ÿ“œ

President vs Governor โ€” Comparison

Interactive
PresidentIndirect election โ€” Electoral College (Parliament + State Assemblies)
GovernorAppointed by President (on advice of PM) โ€” NOT elected
President term5 years โ€” can be re-elected
Governor term5 years โ€” holds office during pleasure of President
Key differencePresident elected, Governor appointed โ€” Governor is Centre agent in state
Practice (SSC): What is the pardoning power of the President (Article 72)? How is it different from Governor (Article 161)?
President pardoning power (Article 72):
โ€ข Pardon โ€” completely absolves the convict of both sentence and conviction
โ€ข Reprieve โ€” temporary suspension of sentence (e.g., stay of execution)
โ€ข Respite โ€” reducing sentence on special grounds (pregnancy, disability)
โ€ข Remission โ€” reducing sentence without changing its character (jail term reduced)
โ€ข Commutation โ€” changing nature of sentence to lighter form (death sentence โ†’ life imprisonment)

President can pardon in cases of:
โ€ข Court-martial (military court)
โ€ข Death penalty cases
โ€ข Offences against Union law

Governor pardoning power (Article 161):
โ€ข All same types EXCEPT cannot pardon death sentence (only President can)
โ€ข Cannot pardon in military court cases
โ€ข Only for offences against state laws

Key difference: Only President can pardon death sentences. Governor cannot.

Process: Both President and Governor act on advice of Council of Ministers โ€” cannot exercise independently. Courts can review if the process was arbitrary (Epuru Sudhakar case 2006).
Practice (SSC): What are the discretionary powers of the President?
Generally the President acts on the advice of Council of Ministers (Article 74). However, the President has some real (not just formal) discretionary powers:

Constitutional discretion:
1. Appointment of PM โ€” when no single party has majority (hung Parliament), President has real choice in inviting someone to form government
2. Dismissal of Council of Ministers โ€” when PM loses Lok Sabha confidence but refuses to resign
3. Dissolution of Lok Sabha โ€” when PM advises dissolution, President can refuse if dissolution is seen as premature
4. Asking PM to prove majority โ€” can send back advice and ask PM to prove majority on floor
5. Suspensive veto โ€” can return ordinary bills once for reconsideration

Situational discretion:
โ€ข When caretaker government is in power
โ€ข Under a constitutional crisis

Important: These are narrow discretionary powers. In normal functioning with clear majority, President must act on PM advice. India has a constitutional monarchy without the monarch โ€” President is constitutional head, real power with PM.
โ†
Previous
Parliament